I was scammed—am I out of luck if I “authorized” a fraudulent transfer via text?
Ludmila Nelipa says the caller told her she was approving a reversal of fraudulent charges. The confirmation texts were real; they came from TD Bank. The caller was an impostor. By the end of the day, $2,500 was gone from her account. TD Bank has now agreed to pay $3.49 million to settle a federal class action brought by customers like her, whose fraud claims it denied because they had approved the bank’s text-message prompts, though the customers say the scammers, not they, started the transfers. The settlement still needs the court’s approval. Under the Electronic Fund Transfer Act, a transfer started by someone other than you without actual authority is unauthorized, and Regulation E’s official interpretation says that includes a transfer started by a person who got your access device from you through fraud. 15 U.S.C. § 1693a(12); 12 C.F.R. pt. 1005, Supp. I, cmt. 2(m)-3.
I regularly handle EFTA suits and arbitrations against banks, and I follow closely how courts treat a bank’s claim that the customer “approved” a scammer’s transaction. In 2023, the United Kingdom adopted rules requiring banks to reimburse many scam victims, and those rules took effect in October 2024. Here in the United States, we still rely on a law from the 1970s, and how it applies to high-tech scams is unsettled. The TD Bank settlement shows what one bank was willing to pay rather than test a common scam defense in a high-stakes class action.
The $3.49 million settlement
On October 23, 2026, the customers asked the federal court in Brooklyn to preliminarily approve a class settlement in Nelipa v. TD Bank, N.A., No. 1:21-cv-01092 (E.D.N.Y.). Under the proposed agreement, TD Bank will pay $3,490,000 into a settlement fund, none of which goes back to the bank. The customers’ lawyers told the court the fund equals more than 70% of the class members’ actual losses. (ECF 98.)
The settlement class is about 3,600 TD Bank customers who reported that they had been tricked into giving someone access to their account, and whose online or app-based (“digital”) fraud claims TD Bank denied between February 18, 2017 and March 4, 2025 for a reason substantially the same as “Evidence shows that an SMS was received and approved by the accountholder’s phone number on file,” where the loss was more than $50. Debit card claims are not included.
Along the way, TD Bank asked the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit for permission to appeal the class-certification order immediately, and the Second Circuit denied the request. The parties mediated before a retired magistrate judge and reported a settlement in principle in September 2026. As of this writing, the court has referred the motion for preliminary approval to the magistrate judge for a recommendation, and the settlement is not final. None of this is a ruling that TD Bank broke the law: certifying the class decided whose claims the case covered, not who would win, and the settlement is a proposal the court has not yet approved.
What happened to the three customers who sued
Three TD Bank customers brought the case. Their stories, as they told them in their 2023 motion for class certification (ECF 44), show how these scams work and how the bank responded. In each case, the customers said, they would have lost at most $500 if TD Bank had treated the transfers as unauthorized. Instead, each lost $1,500 or more.
Ludmila Nelipa and the “reversal code”
On October 22, 2020, Ms. Nelipa got a text on her cell phone that appeared to come from TD Bank’s Fraud Protection Department, asking about a $450 Walmart charge. A few minutes later her phone rang, and the caller ID showed a TD Bank number. The caller said someone was trying to use her debit card for cash transfers and that the bank was starting a fraud prevention process. The number had been spoofed. The caller was a scammer.
While she was on the phone, the scammer started a series of Zelle transfers out of her account to an account called “Rev Code.” Each time TD Bank texted her to confirm a transfer, the scammer told her the text was an automatic message confirming a “reversal code” for the fraudulent charges and told her to approve it. She did, believing she was helping the bank reverse the fraud. By the end of the day, $2,500 was gone in a string of small transfers, the most Zelle allows in a day.
The scammer told her that her account would be frozen and that a new card would arrive in a few days. When no card came, she called TD Bank and learned the bank had never contacted her. On a recording of that call, as one TD employee began relaying her story to the fraud department, the fraud employee cut in almost immediately: “aaand it wasn’t TD Bank…” She filed a police report on November 2. According to the motion, TD Bank denied her claim anyway, classifying it as “non-fraud” because she had confirmed the transfers in response to the bank’s texts.
Allison Archer checked the number first
On January 28, 2021, Ms. Archer got a call from someone she believed was a TD Bank representative, asking about fraudulent charges in Florida and Georgia. She was suspicious at first, so she ran a reverse search on the number. It came back as a TD Bank number. Believing she was helping the bank set up a new account and stop the fraud, she gave the caller her online-banking login. The next day she found more than 28 charges at a Whole Foods in Atlanta, totaling $1,522.28.
She called TD Bank right away. Within days, the bank denied her claim in a letter that said only: “Based on our investigation, we have determined that fraud did not occur.” She filed a police report and gave the bank the report number. A second letter said her provisional credit would be reversed the next day. She disputed again, faxed a detailed, notarized dispute on a branch employee’s advice, and filed a complaint with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. According to the motion, TD Bank kept demanding that she repay $1,557.28. Her charges were debit card transactions, which the bank processed differently, and she later settled her individual claim separately. (ECF 98.)
Verdenia Edwards lost control of her phone
On August 20, 2020, Ms. Edwards got a call from someone claiming to be from Amazon, saying Amazon wanted to refund her for an iPhone she had never bought. The caller said he would add a TD Bank employee to the line to confirm her identity; Ms. Edwards now believes that person was a second impostor. The scammers got remote access to her phone, possibly through malware, signed into her TD Bank account and sent two transfers totaling $1,605: $806 by Western Union and $799 by Zelle.
TD Bank texted her alerts about the transfers, but she couldn’t decline them because the scammers were controlling her phone. She did what the bank told her to do: she disputed the transfers at a branch, closed her account and promptly filed a police report. TD Bank denied her claim, charged her overdraft fees and applied her COVID stimulus payment to the negative balance the theft left behind.
What the law says
The EFTA limits a consumer’s liability for “unauthorized electronic fund transfers,” meaning transfers from a consumer’s account initiated by someone other than the consumer without actual authority, from which the consumer receives no benefit. 15 U.S.C. §§ 1693a(12), 1693g. If you report within two business days of learning of the loss, your liability is generally capped at $50; if you wait longer, it can rise to $500, and more if you miss the 60-day window after your statement. § 1693g(a).
Regulation E’s official interpretation says an unauthorized transfer includes one initiated by a person who obtained the access device from the consumer through fraud or robbery. 12 C.F.R. pt. 1005, Supp. I, cmt. 2(m)-3. In June 2021, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau published FAQs giving examples, such as a scammer who pretends to be from the consumer’s bank and tricks the consumer into giving up login information or a texted confirmation code. Courts have applied the same principle. A federal judge in Manhattan held that “access to account information that was furnished in the first instance under fraudulent pretenses is not ‘authorized’ access under the EFTA.” Green v. Capital One, N.A., 557 F. Supp. 3d 441, 448 (S.D.N.Y. 2021).
A consumer must notify the bank within 60 days after the statement showing the transfer. § 1693f(a). The bank must then investigate, decide whether an error occurred, and correct any error it finds; if it decides there was no error, it must explain why and, on request, give you the documents it relied on. § 1693f; 12 C.F.R. § 1005.11. That investigation is the bank’s duty. Separately, if your claim ends up in a lawsuit or arbitration over your liability for the transfer, the bank bears the burden of proving the transfer was authorized. § 1693g(b). A consumer can sue for actual damages, statutory damages and attorney’s fees, and in some cases treble damages. §§ 1693f(e), 1693m.
The argument that won class certification
The customers argued that TD Bank decided fraud claims the same way for everyone. Its fraud agents followed written procedures and a “Decision Matrix,” and typically copied the reason for a denial from the matrix into the claim file. Critically, the customers said, the bank treated any digital claim where the customer had approved the transaction as a “non-fraud” claim, even when a scammer had obtained the customer’s access or approval by fraud. TD Bank’s corporate representative testified that the bank “treat[s] all of our claims the same way.” (ECF 44.)
Because one denial reason, that a text prompt was received and approved from the customer’s phone, was applied to every class member, the customers argued, whether that practice violates the EFTA and the bank’s deposit agreement is a question that can be answered for everyone at once. Magistrate Judge Joseph A. Marutollo recommended certification, and the bank objected.
What the court held
District Judge LaShann DeArcy Hall sustained the bank’s objections in part and overruled them in part. (ECF 85.) She certified EFTA and breach-of-contract classes of customers whose fraud claims were denied because a text prompt was received and approved from the customer’s phone number on file. Whether denying claims on that basis violates the EFTA and the deposit agreement was a common question that could be resolved “in one fell swoop,” and a class action was superior to individual suits.
The court certified the class on liability only. That means the question of whether TD Bank broke the law would be decided once for everyone; the court did not decide that question either way. Each customer would have proved their own losses later, because those differ. The court also declined, for now, to extend the class to customers the bank denied for other listed reasons, such as having given a third party their online-banking credentials, because the customers had not argued that their claims were typical of those categories. It gave them leave to renew. Nobody’s claim was rejected, and the case settled before the court reached the merits.
Where courts disagree
The hardest line in these cases is between transfers a scammer starts and transfers you start. When a scammer uses your login, your phone or a code you were tricked into sharing, the official interpretation supports treating the transfer as unauthorized. When you send the money yourself, for example by entering a Zelle payment to someone you believe is legitimate, banks generally treat the transfer as authorized, and the law is less favorable to consumers. Approving the bank’s text prompt while a scammer starts the transfer falls in between, which is why this case matters.
The customers’ own lawyers acknowledged the risk when they settled. They told the court the law in this area is “fairly new and evolving,” that their claims relied partly on CFPB guidance that could be withdrawn as the agency pulls back (it withdrew 67 guidance documents in May 2025), and that TD Bank would likely have challenged that guidance under the Supreme Court’s 2024 decision in Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo, which limited how much courts defer to federal agencies’ readings of the law. (ECF 98.) The statute and Regulation E’s official interpretation remain the stronger anchors.
What to do right now
If a scammer posing as your bank, or as a company like Amazon, got money out of your account:
- Call the bank immediately using the number on your card or statement, not a number that called or texted you.
- Dispute every transfer in writing within 60 days of the statement showing it. Tell the bank who entered the payment, what you approved, and what the caller told you the approval would do. 15 U.S.C. § 1693f(a).
- File a police report and an FTC report at ReportFraud.ftc.gov, and give the bank the report numbers.
- Ask for the documents the bank relied on if it denies your claim; you have a right to request them. 12 C.F.R. § 1005.11(d).
- Keep screenshots of the texts, call logs and caller ID, including any spoofed bank number.
- If you were a TD Bank customer whose Zelle or other online-transfer claim was denied between February 2017 and March 2025 because you approved a text, you may be in the settlement class. Watch for a notice if the court approves the settlement, and get advice before deciding whether to stay in or opt out.
How the proposed settlement would pay out
Class members would not have to file a claim form. Each would receive a share of the fund in proportion to the amount of their disputed transfers, after court-approved deductions. The customers’ lawyers are asking for one-third of the fund in fees ($1,163,333.33), $26,037 in expenses and $10,000 each for the two class representatives, and administration is estimated at about $20,000. The customers estimate that class members will receive almost half of what they lost.
Frequently asked questions
I approved the text from my bank. Was the transfer authorized?
- Maybe not. If a scammer started the transfer using access or information they got from you by fraud, Regulation E’s official interpretation treats it as unauthorized, and if your claim ends up in a lawsuit or arbitration, the bank has to prove you authorized it. TD Bank agreed to pay $3.49 million to settle claims that it wrongly denied customers in that situation.
How much did TD Bank agree to pay, and is the settlement final?
- $3,490,000, for about 3,600 customers, under a proposed agreement filed in October 2026. The court still has to approve it. The customers’ lawyers estimate that class members will get almost half of what they lost, after fees and costs.
What if I sent the money myself through Zelle?
- Banks usually treat payments you start as authorized, even if you were deceived, and the law is less clear there. Dispute anyway, and get advice on your specific facts.
How long do I have to report it?
- Report it right away. Under the EFTA, your liability can grow if you wait more than two business days after you learn of the theft, and you generally must notify the bank within 60 days after it sends the statement showing the transfer.
What can I recover?
- Your losses, statutory damages and attorney’s fees, and in some cases three times your losses if the bank didn’t investigate in good faith or had no reasonable basis to deny your claim. 15 U.S.C. §§ 1693f(e), 1693m.
Talk to a lawyer about a denied fraud claim
If your bank denied your fraud claim because you “approved” a scammer’s transfer, send us the denial letter, your statements and the texts. We’ll review them for free. Get a Free Case Review
Sources and authorities
- Nelipa v. TD Bank, N.A., No. 1:21-cv-01092 (E.D.N.Y.): Plaintiffs’ Memorandum in Support of Class Certification, ECF 44 (Nov. 30, 2023)
- Nelipa v. TD Bank, N.A.: Memorandum and Order on class certification, ECF 85 (May 5, 2026)
- Nelipa v. TD Bank, N.A.: Plaintiffs’ Memorandum in Support of Preliminary Approval of Class Action Settlement, ECF 98 (Oct. 23, 2026)
- Nelipa v. TD Bank, N.A.: Second Circuit order denying TD Bank’s Rule 23(f) petition, No. 26-1386 (mandate issued Oct. 9, 2026)
- Electronic Fund Transfer Act, 15 U.S.C. §§ 1693a(12), 1693f, 1693g, 1693m
- Regulation E, 12 C.F.R. §§ 1005.2(m), 1005.6, 1005.11, and Supp. I, cmt. 2(m)-3
- Green v. Capital One, N.A., 557 F. Supp. 3d 441 (S.D.N.Y. 2021)
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Electronic Fund Transfers FAQs (June 4, 2021)
- Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo, 603 U.S. 369 (2024)
Related reading: My bank won’t refund an unauthorized charge — what to do · Wells Fargo denied your fraud claim — what you can do about it · How long does a bank have to investigate a dispute? · Can you recover emotional distress damages under the EFTA?
This article is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Kane Law Firm did not handle the cases discussed. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.
My bank won't refund an unauthorized charge — what to do
EFTA and Regulation E often force the bank to give your money back. Here's how to make it happen.
Unauthorized ChargesWells Fargo denied your fraud claim — what you can do about it
Your EFTA and Regulation E rights after a denied bank fraud claim, what the current account agreement says about arbitration, and what you can recover.
Unauthorized ChargesCan You Recover Emotional Distress Damages Under the EFTA? Yes. Here’s Why.
The EFTA lets you recover for the harm of a drained account, not only the money taken: the statute, the case law, and treble damages.
Chargeback Attorney — Disputed Charges
Force banks and merchants to honor your refund under EFTA, TILA, and FCBA.
Learn moreDisclaimer
This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship between you and Kane Law Firm, LLC or any of its attorneys. Laws vary by state and change over time, and the application of the law to any specific situation depends on the particular facts. Do not act or refrain from acting based on anything you read here without consulting a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction. Contacting us through this website, by email, or by phone does not create an attorney-client relationship; that relationship is formed only by a signed written engagement agreement. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. This material may be considered attorney advertising under the rules of some jurisdictions.