Migliore v. Vision Solar: A Hard Lesson for Identity-Theft Victims on "Permissible Purpose" Claims
Published July 3, 2026
A consumer-unfavorable decision that reshapes identity-theft case architecture in the Third Circuit — and points to the defendants who still owe you the FCRA duties that matter.
The setup
A door-to-door solar salesman forged an elderly consumer's signature on a $99,749.82, 25-year loan. The financing companies pulled her credit report without her knowledge. She sued, arguing they had no permissible purpose to access her file for a transaction she never initiated.
The holding
Migliore v. Vision Solar LLC, No. 24-1679 (3d Cir. Nov. 21, 2025) (precedential). The Third Circuit affirmed dismissal of the FCRA claims against the lenders, holding the "credit transaction involving the consumer" purpose applied:
“A creditor is permitted to obtain a consumer’s credit report ‘to use the information in connection with a “credit transaction involving the consumer.”’”
“Section 1681b(f) bars obtaining or using a credit report for an improper purpose; it does not bar applying for credit by an improper means or in someone else’s name.”
Why it matters — the honest strategic read
Migliore is a consumer-unfavorable decision, and pretending otherwise would be malpractice-adjacent. Its lesson is about case architecture. After Migliore, the strongest identity-theft claims in this circuit usually aren't "you pulled my credit" claims against the defrauded lender — they are:
• Accuracy and reinvestigation claims against the bureaus (see Cushman).
• Investigation claims against furnishers who keep reporting the fraud after dispute (see Ingram, § 1681s-2(b)).
• State-law claims against the actual fraudster and, where it fits, the seller.
Victims should still send police reports and FTC identity-theft affidavits with every dispute. If a forged account is on your report, the case is winnable — it just has to be aimed at the right defendants, which is precisely what an FCRA litigator does. Start at our FCRA attorney page for a free case review.
Cushman v. Trans Union: why credit bureaus can't just parrot the bank
Third Circuit case holding a §1681i reinvestigation must be more than repeating the furnisher — a cornerstone of NJ identity-theft cases.
Case Law LibraryIngram v. Experian: furnishers can't call a CRA-forwarded dispute frivolous
Third Circuit 2023 — a furnisher receiving an indirect dispute must investigate; reasonableness is a jury question.
FCRA Attorney — Case Law Library
The Third Circuit and Supreme Court decisions that decide FCRA cases in New Jersey.
Learn moreDisclaimer
This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship between you and Kane Law Firm, LLC or any of its attorneys. Laws vary by state and change over time, and the application of the law to any specific situation depends on the particular facts. Do not act or refrain from acting based on anything you read here without consulting a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction. Contacting us through this website, by email, or by phone does not create an attorney-client relationship; that relationship is formed only by a signed written engagement agreement. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. This material may be considered attorney advertising under the rules of some jurisdictions.